Change setting to "allowed auth methods"

This allows plaintext password auth to be disabled altogether

config.ini

@@ -17,8 +17,10 @@ acceptallcustomnames=true
 # should attempts to log into non-existent accounts
 # automatically create them?
 autocreateaccounts=true
-# support logging in with auth cookies?
+# list of supported authentication methods (comma-separated)
-useauthcookies=false
+# password = allow login type 1 with plaintext passwords
+# cookie = allow login type 2 with one-shot auth cookies
+authmethods=password
 # how often should everything be flushed to the database?
 # the default is 4 minutes
 dbsaveinterval=240

src/servers/CNLoginServer.cpp

@@ -105,30 +105,20 @@ void loginFail(LoginError errorCode, std::string userLogin, CNSocket* sock) {
 
 void CNLoginServer::login(CNSocket* sock, CNPacketData* data) {
     auto login = (sP_CL2LS_REQ_LOGIN*)data->buf;
-    bool isCookieAuth = login->iLoginType == 2;
 
     std::string userLogin;
-    std::string userPassword;
+    std::string userToken; // could be password or auth cookie
 
     /*
      * The std::string -> char* -> std::string maneuver should remove any
      * trailing garbage after the null terminator.
      */
-    if (isCookieAuth) {
+    if (login->iLoginType == (int32_t)LoginType::COOKIE) {
-        // username encoded in TEGid raw
         userLogin = std::string(AUTOU8(login->szCookie_TEGid).c_str());
-
+        userToken = std::string(AUTOU8(login->szCookie_authid).c_str());
-        // N.B. clients that use web login without proper cookies
-        // send their passwords in the cookie field
-        userPassword = std::string(AUTOU8(login->szCookie_authid).c_str());
     } else {
         userLogin = std::string(AUTOU16TOU8(login->szID).c_str());
-        userPassword = std::string(AUTOU16TOU8(login->szPassword).c_str());
+        userToken = std::string(AUTOU16TOU8(login->szPassword).c_str());
-    }
-
-    if (!settings::USEAUTHCOOKIES) {
-        // use normal login flow
-        isCookieAuth = false;
     }
 
     // check username regex
@@ -145,18 +135,42 @@ void CNLoginServer::login(CNSocket* sock, CNPacketData* data) {
         return loginFail(LoginError::LOGIN_ERROR, userLogin, sock);
     }
 
-    // check password regex if not cookie auth
+    // we only interpret the token as a cookie if cookie login was used and it's allowed.
-    if (!isCookieAuth && !CNLoginServer::isPasswordGood(userPassword)) {
+    // otherwise we interpret it as a password, and this maintains compatibility with
-        // send a custom error message
+    // the auto-login trick used on older clients
-        INITSTRUCT(sP_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE, msg);
+    bool isCookieAuth = login->iLoginType == (int32_t)LoginType::COOKIE
-        std::string text = "Invalid password\n";
+                        && CNLoginServer::isLoginTypeAllowed(LoginType::COOKIE);
-        text += "Password has to be 8 - 32 characters long";
-        U8toU16(text, msg.szAnnounceMsg, sizeof(msg.szAnnounceMsg));
-        msg.iDuringTime = 10;
-        sock->sendPacket(msg, P_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE);
 
-        // we still have to send login fail to prevent softlock
+    // password login checks
-        return loginFail(LoginError::LOGIN_ERROR, userLogin, sock);
+    if (!isCookieAuth) {
+        // bail if password auth isn't allowed
+        if (!CNLoginServer::isLoginTypeAllowed(LoginType::PASSWORD)) {
+            // send a custom error message
+            INITSTRUCT(sP_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE, msg);
+            std::string text = "Password login disabled\n";
+            text += "This server has disabled logging in with plaintext passwords.\n";
+            text += "Please contact an admin for assistance.";
+            U8toU16(text, msg.szAnnounceMsg, sizeof(msg.szAnnounceMsg));
+            msg.iDuringTime = 12;
+            sock->sendPacket(msg, P_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE);
+
+            // we still have to send login fail to prevent softlock
+            return loginFail(LoginError::LOGIN_ERROR, userLogin, sock);
+        }
+
+        // check regex
+        if (!CNLoginServer::isPasswordGood(userToken)) {
+            // send a custom error message
+            INITSTRUCT(sP_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE, msg);
+            std::string text = "Invalid password\n";
+            text += "Password has to be 8 - 32 characters long";
+            U8toU16(text, msg.szAnnounceMsg, sizeof(msg.szAnnounceMsg));
+            msg.iDuringTime = 10;
+            sock->sendPacket(msg, P_FE2CL_GM_REP_PC_ANNOUNCE);
+
+            // we still have to send login fail to prevent softlock
+            return loginFail(LoginError::LOGIN_ERROR, userLogin, sock);
+        }
     }
 
     Database::Account findUser = {};
@@ -166,18 +180,18 @@ void CNLoginServer::login(CNSocket* sock, CNPacketData* data) {
     if (findUser.AccountID == 0) {
         // don't auto-create an account if it's a cookie auth for whatever reason
         if (settings::AUTOCREATEACCOUNTS && !isCookieAuth)
-            return newAccount(sock, userLogin, userPassword, login->iClientVerC);
+            return newAccount(sock, userLogin, userToken, login->iClientVerC);
 
         return loginFail(LoginError::ID_DOESNT_EXIST, userLogin, sock);
     }
 
     if (isCookieAuth) {
-        const char *cookie = userPassword.c_str();
+        const char *cookie = userToken.c_str();
         if (!Database::checkCookie(findUser.AccountID, cookie))
             return loginFail(LoginError::ID_AND_PASSWORD_DO_NOT_MATCH, userLogin, sock);
     } else {
         // simple password check
-        if (!CNLoginServer::isPasswordCorrect(findUser.Password, userPassword))
+        if (!CNLoginServer::isPasswordCorrect(findUser.Password, userToken))
             return loginFail(LoginError::ID_AND_PASSWORD_DO_NOT_MATCH, userLogin, sock);
     }
 
@@ -665,4 +679,18 @@ bool CNLoginServer::isCharacterNameGood(std::string Firstname, std::string Lastn
     std::regex lastnamecheck(R"(((?! )(?!\.)[a-zA-Z0-9]*\.{0,1}(?!\.+ +)[a-zA-Z0-9]* {0,1}(?! +))*$)");
     return (std::regex_match(Firstname, firstnamecheck) && std::regex_match(Lastname, lastnamecheck));
 }
+
+bool CNLoginServer::isLoginTypeAllowed(LoginType loginType) {
+    // the config file specifies "comma-separated" but tbh we don't care
+    switch (loginType)
+    {
+    case LoginType::PASSWORD:
+        return settings::AUTHMETHODS.find("password") != std::string::npos;
+    case LoginType::COOKIE:
+        return settings::AUTHMETHODS.find("cookie") != std::string::npos;
+    default:
+        break;
+    }
+    return false;
+}
 #pragma endregion

src/servers/CNLoginServer.hpp

@@ -23,6 +23,11 @@ enum class LoginError {
     UPDATED_EUALA_REQUIRED = 9
 };
 
+enum class LoginType {
+    PASSWORD = 1,
+    COOKIE = 2
+};
+
 // WARNING: THERE CAN ONLY BE ONE OF THESE SERVERS AT A TIME!!!!!! TODO: change loginSessions & packet handlers to be non-static
 class CNLoginServer : public CNServer {
 private:
@@ -44,6 +49,7 @@ private:
     static bool isPasswordCorrect(std::string actualPassword, std::string tryPassword);
     static bool isAccountInUse(int accountId);
     static bool isCharacterNameGood(std::string Firstname, std::string Lastname);
+    static bool isLoginTypeAllowed(LoginType loginType);
     static void newAccount(CNSocket* sock, std::string userLogin, std::string userPassword, int32_t clientVerC);
     // returns true if success
     static bool exitDuplicate(int accountId);

src/settings.cpp

@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ bool settings::SANDBOX = true;
 int settings::LOGINPORT = 23000;
 bool settings::APPROVEALLNAMES = true;
 bool settings::AUTOCREATEACCOUNTS = true;
-bool settings::USEAUTHCOOKIES = false;
+std::string settings::AUTHMETHODS = "password";
 int settings::DBSAVEINTERVAL = 240;
 
 int settings::SHARDPORT = 23001;
@@ -88,7 +88,7 @@ void settings::init() {
     LOGINPORT = reader.GetInteger("login", "port", LOGINPORT);
     APPROVEALLNAMES = reader.GetBoolean("login", "acceptallcustomnames", APPROVEALLNAMES);
     AUTOCREATEACCOUNTS = reader.GetBoolean("login", "autocreateaccounts", AUTOCREATEACCOUNTS);
-    USEAUTHCOOKIES = reader.GetBoolean("login", "useauthcookies", USEAUTHCOOKIES);
+    AUTHMETHODS = reader.Get("login", "authmethods", AUTHMETHODS);
     DBSAVEINTERVAL = reader.GetInteger("login", "dbsaveinterval", DBSAVEINTERVAL);
     SHARDPORT = reader.GetInteger("shard", "port", SHARDPORT);
     SHARDSERVERIP = reader.Get("shard", "ip", SHARDSERVERIP);

src/settings.hpp

@@ -8,7 +8,7 @@ namespace settings {
     extern int LOGINPORT;
     extern bool APPROVEALLNAMES;
     extern bool AUTOCREATEACCOUNTS;
-    extern bool USEAUTHCOOKIES;
+    extern std::string AUTHMETHODS;
     extern int DBSAVEINTERVAL;
     extern int SHARDPORT;
     extern std::string SHARDSERVERIP;